 |
| Looming above Tbilisis
huge, but financially strapped, Botanical Gardens
and alongside the 4th century Narikala Fortress
is the statue of Mother Georgia, a national
symbol, who greets friends with a wine bowl,
and enemies with a sword |
On the American frontier it was pretty much every
man for himself, no rule of law, with the six-shooter
doing the talking. The Wild East of
early 21st Century Georgia displays its own lawlessness,
manifest by criminal gangs and widespread smuggling,
along with near universal tax avoidance and wide-ranging
corruption in government.
No matter how much selfish individualism might
have existed in the American Wild West
150 years ago it probably could not compare with
the amazing lack of respect shown by Georgias
wild drivers who would as soon run down a pedestrian
as yield in crosswalks or anywhere on
the road. Since the traffic police (GUI, from the
Russian for State Auto Inspectors) are everywhere
one would think they could get things under control.
One would be wrong, for members of the GUI simply
stop cars at random, take a $2.50 bribe and send
the drivers on their way.
In Georgia, a visitor could do worse than follow
the suggestion of a veteran American diplomat who
gave this advice about traveling to Tbilisi: Watch
both ways when you cross the street, and protect
your liver.
The liver of a careful guest can be sheltered from
too much of the excellent Georgian wine, although
it is certainly a central part of the nations
famous hospitality, centered around the supraliterally
feastwith its tamada, or toastmaster,
who makes sure everyone has enough to eat and particularly
to drink.
Georgia has a population of approximately 5 million,
although the exact figure is uncertain since the
last count was in the 1989 Soviet census, which
showed 5.5 million. Many, particularly Russians,
Armenians, Greeks and Jews have left in the last
ten years. About 13,000 Jews remain, some of whose
families were 20th Century migrants from other parts
of the Soviet Union, but a good number have ancestors
who came to Georgia perhaps 2000 years ago.
There is a huge mixture of ethnicity, perhaps 15
major groups, and maybe 80 different peoples living
in Tbilisi with its population of 1.5 million.
The late British author and anthropologist Laurens
van der Post wrote of the Georgians, They
and the Irish both realize the positive creative
uses of irresponsibility. They are an impulsive
and passionate people for whom hospitality and having
a good time are the highest aims. A reporter
visiting in the summer of 2002 can confirm that
observation.
Another student of Georgian culture, Oxford-trained
writer Tim Burford, wrote last year, The Georgians
have managed to dance their way through history
and come out laughing. They grew out of a blend
of Neolithic and Bronze Age cultures, and the present
day nation is a mix of very different types: The
Mingrelians in the west, who are quick, smart, boastful
and cant be stopped from feeding guests; the
naive and funny Svans; the extremely hospitable
and talkative Imeretians; the slow and careful Rachvels;
the political and humorous Gurians; the calm wine-loving
Kakhetians. As for the Adjarians, they are said
to have all the above qualities.
In Georgia when one engages in a discussion about
politics and economics, conversation quickly turns
to one word: Corruption. Improper use of position,
as it is defined, has even generated an official
American explanation, readily available from the
U.S. Embassy, as follows, Traditionally Georgians
have always done whatever is necessary for their
family or clan. When there is a conflict between
family and government little attention is paid to
the needs of the State.
However, the American government is not prominent
in Georgia merely to offer explanations. Millions
of taxpayer dollars are spent annually on efforts
to help root out corruption and build stronger institutions
of government. Democracy and legal reform programs
are budgeted at $23.5 million for 2002. In the words
of a State Department fact sheet, released June
6, 2002, these programs in Georgia, seek to
strengthen non-governmental organizations, independent
media, the judiciary and the next generation of
leaders. Assistance encourages them to be more accountable,
better manage their resources and fight corruption."
Any hesitation about discussing corruption with
government officials, or with ordinary citizens,
goes away after an initial conversation or two.
After the topic of low wages, the problem of official
theft is the biggest issue in Georgian political
life. One top minister told The Washington Times,
I make $500 a month. Imagine how tempting
it is when I see that my simple signature on a piece
of paper could easily put a million dollars in my
bank account. In conversation with government
officials the subject of corruption has two parts,
first, We are making progress by getting rid
of lower and middle level officials who take bribes.
Second, We have a long way to go to get strong,
honest institutions of government.
The habit of taking a bribe, or being readily prepared
to offer one, did not grow up overnight and is not
merely a phenomenon of the new Georgian democracy.
When he was First Secretary of the Communist Party
in the 1970s, Eduard Shevardnadze made his reputation
by purging corruption among Party and government
officials. Much of the life and culture of Georgia
has its roots, as would be naturally expected, in
the Soviet experience, where authorities had huge
powers and citizens were often at their mercy.
As one can observe in other transition societies
there is a concurrent nostalgia for the good old
days of socialism when as a Georgian social scientist,
a demographer, put it, Everyone had a job,
people were given a vision and ideals and rent and
utilities cost little or nothing. It was much better
then. These views echo similar thoughts heard
this summer from a spectrum of Georgians. The past
ten years of early market economics have been extremely
tough on this population, with the loss of the demand
market in the Soviet Union closing down many factories
and ending outlets for what had been a monopoly
in agriculture. Part of the problem is that the
free Russian market now looks elsewhere for product.
Another big requirement is for Georgian business
to learn how to create customers through marketing,
instead of merely fulfilling five-year plans. All
this is new and very difficult.
But a two-month reporting trip through Georgia shows
that thoughtful and aggressive business leaders
are succeeding, particularly those who have an eye
on quality and on finding how to identify and serve
customer needs. After all, the American Wild West,
and its parallel monopoly institutions all over
the U.S. in the gilded age eventually
yielded to a more socially responsible pattern.
Just as the Robber Barons, who dominated the early
industrial age in the United States, found their
match in strong Federal regulatory bodies, so too
will the Wild East be tamed with the maturation
of governance in Georgia. The rule of law will eventually
come also to this young nation, perhaps taking just
a bit longer than one would hope.
|